Some of it is based on good feeling without much thought, but for others it's about maximizing that tax deduction.

I donate to Goodwill and make a point of going through what I don't need and throwing away the stuff that is true junk yet surprisingly enough, when I go down to drop off, I am amazed at the junk that people donate all for their tax deduction. I am talking clothes that are so worn or torn up, they can't be worn again, appliances with cords that are frayed and missing, dishes that are cracked and broken, games that are missing pieces, etc. I talked to one of the guys who works down there and he said they have to through away far more than they can use or sell.

Charity is good, but usable practical charity is even better.

No one should head off to 'help' ill-prepared. While some might seem to think that Haiti needs every bit of help they can get - where are these volunteers supposed to stay/eat - they can't check in at the local Holiday Inn or grab a quick lunch at McD's. Are they carrying enough food and shelter to last them their stay?? I still don't understand how people who aren't part of designated groups are even flying into Haiti - looks like all flights except those part of relief would have been canceled?